When the Bough Breaks is the story of a wealthy New Orleans couple who are down to their final chance at having a baby through surrogacy. Into their lives walks a completely innocent, impossibly sweet young woman named Anna (Jaz Sinclair)—the kind of character who is far too nice for anyone with an IQ higher than single digits to trust. She arrives with her fiancé (Theo Rossi), a man who might as well be wearing a giant neon sign around his neck that reads “I am the villain.” The script is so weak it makes a house of cards look structurally sound, but let’s walk through the details anyway.
Anna quickly takes advantage of Laura’s (Regina Hall) desperate desire for a child. The couple ignores a mountain of red flags the size of the Super Dome just to keep the surrogacy moving forward. Almost immediately things start going wrong. Anna’s fiancé—whose only facial expression appears to be “evil”—assaults her, leading to Anna moving in with John (Morris Chestnut) and Laura until the baby is born. Predictably, Anna develops feelings for John. Despite warning signs bigger and brighter than the Las Vegas Strip, John decides not to tell his wife (or anyone else) what is happening. Eventually Anna runs off with the baby. It turns out she is a full-blown psychotic with a prior body count.
Apparently the high-priced surrogacy agency these people used does not believe in criminal background checks or basic psychological evaluations. The film culminates in a fight of some kind, after which Anna is hit by a car and dies. So… yay?
The single best thing that can be said about When the Bough Breaks is that it becomes genuinely entertaining if you treat it as an unintentional comedy rather than a thriller. The movie is packed with every tired trope from the “obsessed woman destroys perfect couple” subgenre—Obsessed, The Perfect Guy, No Good Deed, and their many cousins all get a workout here, and none of those films were particularly good to begin with. None of the characters think or behave like actual human beings. The drama is dialed up to cartoonish levels. Logic is left at the door along with your coat and any remaining dignity.
If you start asking reasonable questions—How does a lawyer not understand basic surrogacy rights?
How does a court side with someone who is clearly a danger to a child? How does a single detective uncover what a professional agency completely missed?—you are already putting in more effort than the screenwriters did. The film has no interest in answering these questions or in making its plot hold together under the slightest scrutiny. It simply barrels forward from one ridiculous development to the next, confident that the audience will not notice or will not care.
Morris Chestnut and Regina Hall are professional enough to keep straight faces, but the material gives them almost nothing credible to play. Jaz Sinclair commits fully to Anna’s wide-eyed sweetness that slowly curdles into something much darker, yet the performance cannot overcome the sheer absurdity of the writing. Theo Rossi is stuck playing a walking red flag with virtually no dimension beyond menace. The direction by Jon Cassar keeps things moving, but movement is not the same thing as momentum or coherence.
In the end, When the Bough Breaks is the kind of movie that exists primarily to be mocked. If you approach it as a serious psychological thriller, it is a complete failure—poorly written, logically bankrupt, and emotionally hollow. If you approach it as a so-bad-it’s-good comedy about the dumbest wealthy couple in New Orleans and the world’s least subtle surrogate, it can provide a certain masochistic entertainment value. The film never earns genuine tension or scares; it only earns eye-rolls, incredulous laughter, and the repeated question of how something this silly made it to theaters with a straight face.
There is a long tradition of “Fatal Attraction for the new millennium” knock-offs. When the Bough Breaks does not improve upon any of them. It simply joins the pile, waving its red flags proudly and daring the audience not to laugh. Most viewers will accept that dare.
1/5
Society Reviews 
Leave a comment