Film Reviews

Mulan (2020) Review: Disney’s Boring Love Letter To The Chinese Government

A film that was never made for Western audiences now expects a western bailout from a massive financial failure.

Disney’s live action reboot of Mulan has been an unmitigated disaster from jump street.

A film that spent 10 years in development hell only to finally get green lit and sold as an attempted cash grab of the communist Chinese government has been a story far better than anything in film itself has to offer. 

Disney made no bones in Mulan’s production that this film was created to pander to the Chinese market as much as possible. Awarded with a 200 million budget, Disney hoped that China would return their investment in full. Mulan took no shortcut to make sure that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) were pleased with every aspect of the film. This was NOT a film made for western audiences, this was all for China.

The concessions Disney made for China included adding themes that were friendly to Chinese History, elements such as on screen romances were censored at the Government’s request, Disney even went as far to film a majority of the film in the city of Uyghurs which is currently under fire for running Muslim concentration camps full of hard labor and torture. Disney even thanked the city in it’s end credits.

This is how far Disney was willingly to go to get that Chinese money, so what happened next was karma. The Chinese Coronavirus spread worldwide from its origin in Wuhan effectively shutting down movie theaters all over the planet. The virus has cost Hollywood billions of dollars and Disney is one of the hardest hit studios. 

Mulan was originally scheduled for a November 2, 2018 release but was delayed in favor of reshoots and CCP approval. Then the coronavirus outbreak shut down theaters delaying the release of the film 4 times in 6 months. The final straw came when Chinese citizens waged a boycott of the film due to lead actress Liu Yifei’s past comments in which she supported Communist China’s crackdown on demonstrators in the Hong Kong conflict.

It became clear that Disney was not going to get their money back from China like they had hoped. In an attempt to save face, Disney crawled back to Western audiences and offered the long delayed film on their streaming service Disney Plus for a one time payment of $29.99. Every minute there is a sucker born and if you spent $30 on this, you are the sucker.

Mulan as a live action remake of the 1998 animated film that drastically changes major details of the original. Set in rural imperial China, Mulan is an adventurous young girl who is already awesome at everything but even she can’t overcome her parent’s disappointment of not being married. However, when the reality of war comes to Mulan’s doorstep, she realizes that her father could not survive the fight, so she decides to take his place but little do the boys know, she is the bravest soldier of them all and the best fighter in the whole squad (actual quote). Mulan could have won this entire war herself if it wasn’t for her archenemy…another woman.

Mulan is a boring two hour love letter to the Communist party of China injected with some poor Disney feminist storytelling. Much like Rey from Star Wars, Disney Mary Sues the shit outta Mulan taking away all points of emotion and empathy you had from the original cartoon. Mulan does not grow over the course of her adventure because she is already great at everything from the start. There are no obstacles to overcome because she already overcame them before the opening credits. 

The feminist message of women are awesome and only have the potential to be even better creates a boring soulless protagonist with no stakes to invest your interest in.  

Many will praise the film for its visual look and technical aspects but given it’s quarter of a billion dollar budget, having something good to look at would seem like the bare minimum of achievements. The dialogue is rotten even for a Disney movie, the acting is poor because they opted to go with authentic Chinese actors over…good actors. Disney could have gotten away with it’s Chinese cash grab if it was mediocre but there is nothing positive to praise about this film.

A film that was never made for Western audiences now expects a western bailout from a massive financial failure. Audiences are better off treating Mulan (2020) like the Chinese treat Hong Kong protesters.

 

$

 

Don’t Forget to Like and Subscribe to Twitter  For Updates. Also, Follow This Blog at Society-Reviews

4 comments on “Mulan (2020) Review: Disney’s Boring Love Letter To The Chinese Government

  1. Cyborgjustice

    That’s the biggest problem with this movie. Disney decides to ignore the bad elements of China’s history. A great person once said “If we don’t learn from history, we’re doomed to repeat it”. Too bad both Disney and Xi Jinping don’t get the memo.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I miss Hong Kong kung fu movies. One of the charms of the Hong Kong kung fu movies was their small budgets, the tongue in cheek humor and the cleverness they used to get around it. The plots were generally simple so the emphasis could be on the action. They used actors with amazing skills but with great screen charisma. When the Communists shut down Hong Kong film making the government made a number of “epic” Kung fu movies with big budgets featuring Chinese history plots that were, IMO, generally snooze fests. Apparently they decided to continue the genre but with Disney’s money.

    A point you didn’t mention: the director was a New Zealand woman, Niki Caro, who hasn’t directed any movies with a budget over 20m before. So they not only put together a Chinese vanity movie with a western feminist subtext – they used an inexperienced woman director that had done nothing like a kung fu action movie. I suppose Taiwan’s Ang Lee would have been a very literally politically incorrect choice for the job. .

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hollywood is doing that ALOT these days, putting women with VERY little experience in directing in charge of major release just for the sake of “diversity”. It won’t get any better anytime soon.

      Like

  3. “Mulan could have won this entire war herself if it wasn’t for her archenemy…another woman.”

    Hah! That’s the thing though, I didn’t find this movie all that boring (well, except for portions of the middle act). This film is downright unintentionally hilarious. How can you not laugh at this crap? My review looks at it from another angle:
    https://theanomaloushost.org/2020/09/09/mulan-2020-review-and-comparison-to-the-1998-animated-version/

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: