It’s been a rough stretch for Tim Burton. Several of his recent films have taken a beating from critics, and it’s hard to ignore that most of them also featured Johnny Depp. If there is one creative pairing many of us would be happy to see permanently retired, it is Burton and Depp. Fortunately, Depp has nothing to do with this project, which at least opens the door to a better outcome. Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children—a title that is almost as cumbersome to say as it is to type—is based on the 2011 novel of the same name. Once the rights were secured, the studio brought Burton on board primarily as director, a decision that makes sense.
Love or hate his work, almost no one disputes that Burton’s films are visual events. The remaining question is whether the rest of the movie can rise to the same level.The story follows teenager Jake (Asa Butterfield) as he investigates the mysterious death of his grandfather in Florida. The old man’s eyes have been removed, and the circumstances force Jake to reconsider the wild stories his grandfather used to tell about a special group of children living in Wales. Accompanied by his father, Jake travels to the island to determine whether those tales were pure fantasy or something more.For anyone unfamiliar with the concept, the “peculiar children” function a bit like a younger, more whimsical version of the X-Men.
Their protector and stand-in for Professor X is Miss Alma LeFay Peregrine (Eva Green), whose sole purpose is to keep the children safe. Each child possesses a distinct ability—fire creation, super strength, invisibility, and others. Jake learns that they exist inside a time loop, forever reliving a single day in 1943. On that day a German bomb destroyed their home; by resetting the loop, Miss Peregrine prevents the children from aging into the present, where they would rapidly grow old and die. The arrangement is essentially a form of permanent purgatory: they must repeat the same day indefinitely or face a far worse fate. Coming from Tim Burton, the darker undertone should surprise no one.The film builds an intriguing atmosphere in its first half.
Once the children and their peculiar world are introduced, there is genuine curiosity about how Jake will fit in and what threatens them. Unfortunately, the story begins to lose momentum around the midpoint, particularly after Samuel L. Jackson’s villain becomes a more active presence. Burton himself feels somewhat restrained here. While the production design is still distinctive, the movie lacks the consistently striking, imaginative set pieces that usually define his stronger work. There are a couple of memorable visual sequences, but overall the film feels more muted than expected from a director known for such vivid style.
Eva Green is the clear standout. She plays Miss Peregrine with a crisp, no-nonsense authority that lands somewhere between strict headmistress and slightly otherworldly guardian; it is the most fully realized performance in the film. The younger leads, Asa Butterfield and Ella Purnell, are serviceable but rarely memorable. Supporting players fill their roles adequately without leaving a strong impression.In the end, Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children is a solid, watchable effort that never quite becomes more than the sum of its parts.
The premise is appealing, the central performance by Green is excellent, and the production still carries enough Burton flavor to remain interesting to look at. Yet the narrative grows diffuse, the visual invention feels dialed down, and the emotional stakes never fully take hold. It is a middle-of-the-road entry in Burton’s filmography—neither a return to form nor a disaster, but a film that leaves you wishing it had stuck the landing more cleanly.
3/5
Society Reviews 
Leave a comment